In early May 2025, a storm of criticism descended on P-pop girl group BINI following the circulation of a video that sparked outrage across social media platforms. The footage, which appeared to show three of the group’s members—Jhoanna, Stacey, and Colet—engaged in what many interpreted as insensitive and inappropriate joking, led to widespread disappointment and demands for accountability.
The video in question first appeared on X (formerly Twitter), posted by user @BaliLeeg. It depicted a casual hangout that turned controversial. In the scene, Ethan David of the P-pop boy group GAT and professional dancer Shawn Castro were roughhousing in front of a seated Jhoanna, who was seen laughing. What followed prompted a wave of online criticism. In the background, a woman believed to be Stacey was heard saying, “Ganyan ginagawa niya kay Ashley… Sinasabunutan,” loosely translating to, “That’s what he does to Ashley… He pulls her hair.” Then another voice, alleged to be Colet’s, added, “Oo, 13 years old,” to which Jhoanna repeated, “Ah, 13 years old.”
This exchange triggered intense reaction online. Viewers condemned the clip, interpreting it as a joke made at the expense of a child and linking it to themes such as abuse and exploitation. What may have been dismissed as an offhand comment by those present quickly turned into a contentious debate across fan communities and beyond.
Fans Demand Responsibility
As the video spread, fans expressed not only shock but also deep disappointment. Many supporters of BINI—collectively known as “Blooms”—had always seen the group as a representation of confidence, positivity, and women’s strength. A key point of contention for many fans was the perception that the group had violated the values it claimed to promote.
Bloom Philippines, one of the fan clubs associated with BINI, released a statement on X requesting a clear response from both the group and their management. The message underscored the group’s mission of advocating for women and asked the involved members to take responsibility for what was said and done in the video.
“The joke may have been spontaneous, but it touched on topics that should never be taken lightly,” read one fan comment. Another user added, “You can’t champion women’s rights and at the same time laugh at references to grooming or hurting children. It doesn’t work like that.”
This sentiment echoed widely. For a group that has built much of its identity on empowerment and integrity, the video posed a real threat to its credibility.
Official Response
Two days after the video gained traction online, BINI posted an official statement on their social media channels. All eight members, including the three involved in the controversy, signed off on the apology. In the message, they expressed regret and acknowledged the seriousness of the issue.
“We know that the past couple of days have been triggering and disappointing for all of you. Sincerely, we understand where all of those feelings are coming from,” the statement began.
It continued by acknowledging the video as a “private moment with friends” but emphasized that they were not offering that as an excuse. “We offer no excuse for our actions, reactions, and choice of words. We take full accountability. Nagkamali kami,” it read.
This public admission was followed by an apology to their fans, families, and the wider public. “We humbly ask for a chance to reflect on and learn from our mistakes and continue to work on becoming better versions of ourselves.”
Some fans praised the statement for its honesty and humility, while others felt it didn’t go far enough. “Acknowledging the mistake is the first step. But what they do next matters more,” one fan noted.
The Role of Ethan David and Shawn Castro
The men who appeared in the video—Ethan David and Shawn Castro—also issued public apologies, acknowledging their part in the controversy.
David’s apology came through his talent agency, Viva Artists Agency, which posted a message on Facebook: “Humihingi po ako ng kapatawaran sa mga nasaktan at na-disappoint sa akin. Nais ko pong ipahayag na malaki po ang respeto ko sa lahat ng tao lalong lalo na sa kababaihan…”
In his own words, he expressed remorse and a commitment not to repeat the behavior.
Shawn Castro also addressed the issue directly on Instagram. “Inaamin po namin na mali kami in so many ways with that joke,” he wrote, admitting fault without deflecting blame.
Both apologies attempted to confront the criticism head-on, yet they too were met with mixed reception. Some users questioned whether these were sincere reflections or merely attempts at damage control.
A Closer Look at Celebrity Responsibility
This controversy has brought into sharper focus the expectations placed on public figures, especially in entertainment. P-pop idols like BINI carry the weight of intense visibility. Their actions, even in seemingly private moments, are often scrutinized under a microscope.
The line between public and private life continues to blur, particularly for performers who build a brand centered on values. Fans feel deeply invested in the groups they follow. They are not just consumers of music or dance—they are part of a shared identity. When that identity is called into question, the fallout can be intense.
As with many public missteps, some of the backlash turned personal. Harsh criticism, hate speech, and even threats began to appear in the comments directed at the artists. This raises another complex issue: where does fair accountability end and online harassment begin?
Moving Forward
BINI’s statement ended with a promise to learn and grow from the experience. While words can express regret, actions are likely to speak louder in the coming months.
Observers are now waiting to see if BINI, along with their management and collaborators, will take steps that go beyond apologies. These could include sensitivity training, open dialogue with fans, or supporting child advocacy organizations. Taking active steps to confront the themes raised by the controversy may help regain the trust they lost.
This situation also serves as a reminder to both celebrities and fans alike: humor can sometimes tread into harmful territory, especially when it touches on subjects involving children or abuse. What feels lighthearted in private may take on an entirely different meaning when viewed through a public lens.
For now, BINI finds itself at a crossroads. The controversy may not define them, but how they respond will certainly shape how they are seen from this point forward.
Conclusion
The BINI video controversy has stirred uncomfortable conversations—not only within fan circles but also in wider discussions about accountability, influence, and responsibility. The group, once widely celebrated for their fresh energy and values-driven messaging, now faces the task of regaining public trust.
While the video itself may fade from headlines in time, the questions it raised about celebrity behavior and sensitivity to serious issues will likely linger. For BINI, the path ahead is one of repair, reflection, and the possibility of redemption—one that will require more than just words.